Nutrition Hotline
by Reed Mangels, PhD, RD
This issue’s Nutrition Hotline explains what kidney stones are, discusses which populations are most likely to develop them, and suggests some dietary tips that may help to reduce the risk of their formation.
QUESTION: “What causes kidney stones? Are there dietary changes that can reduce the risk of kidney stones? Are there different factors for young people?”
A.R., via e-mail
ANSWER: Kidney stones are one of the most common and one of the most painful disorders of the urinary tract. In 2000, more than 600,000 people visited the emergency room because of kidney stones. They are much more common in men than in women; 80 percent of people who develop kidney stones are men. Although kidney stones can occur at any age, they are most common in men in their 40s or older and in women in their 50s. Kidney stones in children are usually due to a genetic condition.
Kidney stones develop when crystals separate from the urine and build up. Usually, urine contains substances that prevent these crystals from forming or limit the size of these crystals. If the crystals combine and produce a large enough stone, it can block urine flow and cause extreme pain.
Kidney stones are categorized by their chemical composition. The most common type of stones contain calcium, either as calcium oxalate or as calcium phosphate. Less common types include struvite stones, which are caused by an infection, and uric acid stones.
Many factors can increase one’s risk of developing kidney stones. These include a family history of kidney stones, recurrent urinary infections, bowel disease, some kidney diseases, certain drugs (including some diuretics, antacids, and steroids), prolonged bed rest, and metabolic disorders. Dehydration, which can be due to heavy sweating or to inadequate fluid intake, can lead to kidney stone formation. The National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases (NIDDK) recommends drinking enough liquid to produce at least 2 quarts of urine daily if you are susceptible to kidney stones.
Diet also appears to play a role in the formation of some types of kidney stones. Approximately 70 to 80 percent of kidney stones are calcium oxalate and calcium phosphate stones. This type of kidney stone is often due to too much calcium in the urine, a condition called hypercalciuria. Hypercalciuria can be caused by an inherited disorder or by some medications.
It may seem that high dietary calcium could lead to this type of kidney stone. Actually, low calcium intakes are much more likely to lead to calcium oxalate stones and higher calcium intakes to lead to a reduced risk. Apparently, dietary calcium limits the amount of oxalate that is absorbed, and it is excess oxalate that can cause calcium oxalate stones to form. Health care providers may tell people with a history of calcium oxalate stones to limit their use of high oxalate foods and to avoid large doses of vitamin C that can lead to excess oxalate in the urine.
In addition, diet can influence urinary calcium levels. Hypercalciuria can be caused by excess intakes of meat, fish, and poultry and by excess sodium. A high intake of potassium, a mineral found in fruits and vegetables, is associated with a reduced risk of kidney stones.
Another kind of kidney stone, uric acid stones, is not as common as calcium oxalate stones. Uric acid stones contain uric acid and are more common in people with gout. Recommendations for reducing the risk of developing uric acid stones include limiting meat products and alcohol since consuming these products can worsen gout. Scientists believe that dietary changes, like eating little or no meat, fish, or poultry and increasing fluid, calcium, and potassium intakes are helpful in reducing risk in those who are susceptible to developing kidney stones.
